Saturday, 6 July 2013

Morals Post - a qualification

On the Other Hand, Maybe I should qualify that !


I've just been reading Justin Welby's (Archbishop of Canterbury and whilst not the head, definitely a leading light in the worldwide Anglican Church) address to the English Anglican general synod. The link is

Reading his speech I really thank God that he has got Justin to be in that leading position. However one cultural difference struck me.

His English background is one where the “Church of England” was very closely linked to the government of England. Even in the olden days when Kings of England ruled without a parliament the church wielded a great deal of power. So the idea of the Anglican Church through its committees or bishops directly influencing government policy is part of their inherited culture.

As an Australian born and bred (my forebears came here in the early 1800's – some as free settlers, some in chains as convicts {one stole a sheep!}) I have a different cultural inheritance. From its inception as a colony, Australians refused to have any “established church”. This was to be a free country where no denominational church had the government in its pocket (or vice versa!). Well that was the stated intent. In practice human nature being what it is there has been “argy-bargy” and horse trading between government and denominations.

In Australia today there is a paradoxical situation. Denominational leaders do try to push their own political views – which are not necessarily those of their adherents, or particularly “Christian”). Often they try to tell the people who really have been elected to run the country how they should do their job. (which in my previous post I said was not how I thought churches should act).

On the other side we have very vocal groups who oppose Christianity and everything it stands for. They push the idea that “separation of church and state” means that people who hold Christian beliefs should be gagged and not allowed to make public comments or if elected to parliament not allowed to let their Christian faith influence how they run the country. This is an even worse situation!

My arguments leading up to this point have been aimed at this false secularism ideology. This is the ideology which has been infiltrating the western world. I suppose its effect is strongest in Europe – especially the “Eurozone”. Closely followed by England. Australia seems to be about 40years behind England in this influence.

I am not supporting an “established church” as a political power. Historically that has worked out very badly. I am not advocating the sort of regimes we see now being imposed by Islamists with their draconian “Sharia Law”. The military intervention we have seen this week in Egypt with the army deposing a “Muslim Brotherhood” president who was not ruling in the best interests of the majority Egyptians, has shown that even Muslims do not necessarily want this sort of state.


So I had better spend the next few posts examining what I do want to propose as a model for Christian ethics in a modern democracy.                

Friday, 5 July 2013

Galatians 5 - preached 30 June 2013

Galatians 5 is really exciting - how we can rise about our human nature by the Holy Spirit (with our active participation of course)

Galatians 5 - sermon 30 June 2013

Wednesday, 3 July 2013

Adding to the Gospel heresy No.4 : Science or Religion

“As a Christian you must now believe “science is bad” and/or “the world was created in 6 (solar) days”.

This one is, unfortunately, very common especially in more evangelical and fundamentalist circles. It results in people rejecting Christianity (wrongly) believing it is anti-science, or being sidetracked from devotion to Christ alone into fighting for the “cause” of creation science etc. I am dealing with it here because of its danger as an addition to the Gospel, but at the same time I will comment on the false “Christianity vs. Science” dichotomy.

I grew up in a denomination which although it contained many devout and godly Christians had fallen into an “adding the Gospel” trap with creationism (and also special foods and Sabbath). So I do have some first hand knowledge. I also remember vividly as a young teenager keenly interested I science what a put-off it was hearing science denounced from the pulpit, and how silly preachers sounded who railed at scientific things which they very obviously did not understand!

When I was studying for my High School finals, I was taking Geology as an extra science subject. One of my younger cousins, who still belonged to that denomination came into my room one day. As he saw me sitting there surrounded by geology textbooks his look turned to horror and he blurted out “But you do believe in God don’t you?”

So let me cover the “science is bad” fallacy in a few words first.

The fallacy has been fed by atheists opposed to Christianity – from Darwin to Dawkins - who have tried to use science in their cause. So what if they used science as a weapon, it was them not science that was anti-Christian. It has also been fed by the more fundamentalist preachers who made two mistakes. Firstly did not realise that the real answer to the atheist scientists’ attacks is to remember that science deals with the question “how” while theology deals with the question “why”. Neither has anything to fear from the other. Secondly these preachers have very in-advisably tried to use Genesis as a science text book (I will deal more with that later).

What is modern science? It is a search for truth. It is a search for answers to the question “how?” in relation to this world. And modern science is the child of devout Christians of long ago who, because they believed God created everything and that God was dependable, believed that there would be a “rhyme and reason” to the world and so they confidently looked for it and discovered things like the ‘laws’ of physics.

So what is “bad” about science? Jesus said “I am the Truth” so searching for truth cannot be bad.

Especially for us who believe God created everything, discovering the “how” of his creation should be an exciting and noble thing.

The scientific enterprise, scientific mindset and scientific method are things that we Christians should thanking God for, not disavowing and most certainly not stigmatising as bad.

Back to creationism as an addition to the Gospel.

You may have seen news clips of conflict in the United States at various times with people objection violently to “evolution” being taught in schools and wanting “creationism” taught alongside it. The passion with which these people pursue their cause is testament to the importance they attach to it. In Australia you will find churches, and may even have joined a church, that hold creationism with similar passion. In that case it has changed from being a matter in which a Christian can believe whatever they like to a heresy because it is pulling people away from devotion to Christ.

My aim here is most certainly not to get into an argument on the actual subject of “creationism Vs evolution”. That is the very last thing I want to do. What I want to do is show that it is not an essential part of Christian belief, but rather a matter on which every Christian has – and should extent to others – freedom to hold whatever views they like. Especially I want to show that elevating it to an Article of Faith makes it into a heresy.

How do I show it is not an essential Christian belief? Here goes…

When I was at theological college I had two very good Old Testament lecturers. One was Dr. Bill Dumbrell. He was a devout Christian (rare I am afraid in Biblical scholars) and a formidable scholar. At the start of a one semester unit on “Genesis chapters 1 to 11” he started by dictating the names of good reference books which we slavishly wrote down. He seemed bemused that we all dropped our pens when, after one book he added what he obviously thought was a matter of no consequence: “It is several hundred pages … in German” He was that sort of scholar! One lesson someone asked him if he believed the world was created in six days. His answer was very interesting. He said that if he found that a sound interpretation of the Bible required that belief, then he would believe it without hesitation. But that in fact he did not believe that the Bible said that. And he went on to talk about the way the Bible used the word “day” and other items which I won’t digress on to here.

I realise that his belief does not prove anything, but it does give us a good reason not to allow ourselves to be swept along by claims that the Bible “obviously” says the world was created in six solar days.

My next reason is to do with Gallileo. In 1633 Galileo was condemned to prison by a church Inquisition for the heresy of “holding as true the fallacy that the sun is at the centre …”

In 1992 the then pope said this:
Thanks to his intuition as a brilliant physicist and by relying on different arguments, Galileo, who practically invented the experimental method, understood why only the sun could function as the centre of the world, as it was then known, that is to say, as a planetary system. The error of the theologians of the time, when they maintained the centrality of the Earth, was to think that our understanding of the physical world's structure was, in some way, imposed by the literal sense of Sacred Scripture....
—Pope John Paul II, L'Osservatore Romano N. 44 (1264) - November 4, 1992
So Galileo was condemned because the theologians of his time believed the Bible said that the earth was the centre of the universe and the sun went around the earth. I do not think any Christian today would believe the sun goes round the earth, but we still read the same passages out of the same Bible as those theologians did.

So when today we have scientists saying that the evidence appears to show that the world came to be in such and such a way we should be cautious about acting like the Inquisition of Galileo’s day and declaring “No! It cannot be! The Bible says it happened in six days!” The Bible has important things to say about why the world around us is the way it is and why evil exists, and what God has done about it and how we should live to please God. These are the things that really matter. So the Bible may not have the least interest in teaching spiritually unimportant things like the world’s physical structure.


My last reason is in the answer to this question: “What difference would it make to our faith?”

I don’t have any difficulty in believing God could create the universe in an instant let alone over six days. But what if the modern scientific theory is correct (and of course it may be supplanted by another theory in time); what changes in my appreciation of God?

Well if I imagine God putting forth some stupendous burst of pure energy, bounding it I suppose by what we know as the laws of physics, watching for billions of years while nebulae, galaxies and solar systems form knowing that out of all this vast array of stars at least one will have a suitable planet for life. Perhaps he does or perhaps he does not kick start that first anaerobic life. (He may for all I know have set up the whole thing to run to produce his desired result without further intervention – that would be very clever indeed!) If I imagine him watching as this world is “polluted” by oxygen (a biologist called it the earth’s greatest ecological disaster) and most life forms are killed off. Then as oxygen-based life flourishes he does or perhaps does not need to give it a push here and a shove there. Then as millions of years roll by he may or may not tweak things so that something recognisably human emerges. Perhaps there is indeed a first breeding pair who are “human” maybe he starts to talk to them and gives them a really simple test of obedience “don’t eat the fruit of this tree” …

I am no biologist and I may not have done the current theories of astronomy and evolution justice, but my point is that such an account is to me just as glorifying to God, and does not detract from any essential piece of doctrine that I know.

On the other hand treating Genesis as a science text book does divert attention away from the really fundamental doctrines it sets forth. Doctrines of how evil come into the world – we humans let it in; doctrines of why we suffer natural disasters – because we humans decided to try to run the world instead of God; of God’s kindness – that despite what we did, God did not totally stop helping us; of the beginning of God’s way of setting to rights what we humans had made wrong. These teachings are really important, and they are what Genesis is really about.

There is a justly famous principle of the English reformation:
"in essentials, unity; in doubtful matters, liberty; in all things, charity." 
This principle is a very good one to apply to “Creation Vs Evolution”. The question of which is correct is not an essential of the Christian Faith, rather it is definitely a “doubtful matter” so the correct approach is “liberty”. Believe what you believe, but grant other Christians the same liberty to believe what they believe. That way you will avoid turning you pet belief into a heresy that harms your Christian life and growth.

As Paul wrote of a different but I think analogous situation (Titus 3.9)

“9 But avoid foolish controversies and genealogies and arguments and quarrels about the law, because these are unprofitable and useless.”

Morals post: Off The Cliff on a Hang-Glider !



Yes. Flying is definitely the way to do it!

Last time (I would like to say “last week” but I'm running late again!) I told the story of Colonel Patterson and the pair of huge (they are now in the Chicago Museum) rogue male man eating tigers so fierce that his workforce thought they were demons and un-killable. Patterson did not let these claims spook him but trusting in the rifle he had used in the past hunted and eventually killed them.

So how does his example solve my problem with moral theories?

Simple! Well simple after you think of it.

People who want to work out a moral system starting with the assumption “there is no God” are just like the people who thought that the tigers “the Ghost” & “The Darkness” could not be killed with bullets. They have been proclaiming for the last half century or more that one cannot bring religion into moral discussions.

Christian moralists on the other hand have been nothing like Colonel Patterson. We have believed the atheists without question! We have blindly accepted the notion that Christian ideals and Biblical insights have no place in determining "right” and “wrong” human conduct. We have followed the atheists like lambs to the slaughter, even whole churches throwing away their moral heritage in order to run after the latest non-Christian (or even straight out anti-Christian) fashion in morals.

I would like to sound surprised that we have been so stupid … but God's people have a long history of such stupidity. For instance Jeremiah prophesied to his generation:
    “My people have committed two sins: They have forsaken me, the spring of living water, and have dug their own cisterns, broken cisterns that cannot hold water.
    Jeremiah 2:12-14
But that does not excuse us! If Patterson had acted as we have done he would have packed away his rifle believing it was useless and gone back to England leaving the local Africans to be eaten by the lions! Come to think of it, we have left people – not to be eaten by lions but to have their lives and the lives of others damaged and even destroyed for lack of moral teaching based on how the world really is.

But luckily for the Africans, Patterson had more sense than us. He used his rifle. It did work.

So my simple way off the cliff is to recognize the claims of atheist moralists for the sham they are! 

I had already worked out that if there is no God, then there is no basis for moral argument at all, but if God is, then the real – and only – basis for moral argument is God's moral character.

Use the rifle stupid!

The way forward is for  there to be effective Christian moralists. Competent moralists who unashamedly base their work on God. Who refuse to engage on any other ethical theory.

The first problem I see is that after decades of total surrender to atheist theories, I don't know how many Christian moralists are capable of doing this! I got involved in studying moral philosophy precisely because I was appalled that my own denomination was putting out material that a first year philosophy student should have been ashamed to hand in! I mean they were not only unthinkingly trotting out the atheist line but with such wooly thinking that they had none of the rigour that even atheist ethicists were bringing to their work. It was truly embarrassing!

The second problem is that finding out how God's moral character answers complex modern situations is a participatory thing. That is it involves practical, not theoretical exercises. It is not just a matter of reading the Bible the way a sharp lawyer might read the statute books – Jesus versus the Pharisees demonstrates that. It involves a relationship with God, certainly with much reading the Bible, but then putting into practice ourselves what we learn.

Actually it is more accurately being active participants in the real life process of God re-creating us from the inside out.

The Bible study then becomes an iterative experience. We learn a bit about God, we are drawn to that, he makes an incremental change in our outlook, from this improved “viewpoint” we can see a little better to understand what the Bible is saying, so we learn a bit more about God …. and so on ….for the rest of our lives.

This is SO different from studying the Bible in a theoretical way that it is really not surprising that such people have throughout history “proved” the wackiest things from the Bible

I heard a great line condemning a preacher which went: “He uses the Bible the way a drunk uses a lamppost – more for support than for illumination”

Also in this modern world of specialised knowledge, the complexities of moral problems faced by someone in a particular field are not likely to be fully understood by the Bible “expert”. So for instance, church leaders pontificating on what scientists, medical practitioners, business or union people, or for that matter leaders of government should do in this case or that case is not the way. The real way is for churches to be helping “lay” people in this process of knowing and being inwardly renewed by God. Then these people – the ones who are actually engaged in these fields – can apply general principles to work out and adopt the right course of action.

So the task of recovering the proper place of Christian morals is an extremely difficult one. But it all starts with recovering confidence. There is a God. So moral discussion must revolve around him. “God was in Christ Jesus reconciling the world to himself” - so we must never be ashamed of our Christian heritage and Biblical understanding of God and human nature. We should however be utterly ashamed and stung into doing better when non-Christians using what revelation they have, manage to outdo us in embodying God's character.




Wednesday, 26 June 2013

Adding to the Gospel heresy : Post 3

3. “You believe in Jesus …. Now you need to give up smoking / lose weight / join XYZ social action cause … etc.”


I have lumped a few disparate things together just to illustrate the sort of thing you may be exhorted to do as part of your new found faith. Don’t fall for it for a moment! Remember what Paul said to the Christians in Galatia!

Any one of them may be harmless in themselves, they may even be good things BUT the moment they become added as something necessary to complete your faith in Jesus they become spiritual poison.

Take smoking. Giving it up is sound medical advice, but it is not a matter of salvation. It may seem harmless to people to just add it in as an article of faith, but the spiritual effect of that is like putting carbon monoxide into the air we breathe.

A number of people I know found that not long after they came to faith the Holy Spirit laid it on them to give up their cigarette habit and the Holy Spirit gave them the strength and encouragement to do it. That is the sort of thing the Holy Spirit does in a believer’s life as much as we will allow. But it is the Holy Spirit who decides what aspects of our life need changing and in what order. The Holy Spirit brings us around to agree to each change in turn and gives us the power to do it. For other humans to try to set the agenda for us is really not helpful.

With things like losing weight it is again a problem of “doing the right thing for the wrong reason. On the personal level you might decide to do it for health reasons: that’s fine. You may decide to do it for aesthetics: that’s fine too (within reason of course). But being overweight is not a sin. (of course gluttony where a person turns food into something they effectively worship IS a sin (Philippians 3.19 “18 For, as I have often told you before and now tell you again even with tears, many live as enemies of the cross of Christ. 19 Their destiny is destruction, their god is their stomach, and their glory is in their shame. Their mind is set on earthly things.”) but I am not talking now about the sin of making an idol of our appetites. What I am talking about is the danger of Christians who try to mix in belief in “healthy living” – which is one of the false religions of our age – to faith in Jesus. 

On the subject of telling other people what to do let me illustrate it by “wrong way / right way” examples:

Right way: Suppose you are involved in some way in public health. Through this you have a concern that obesity is a widespread health problem. As a Christian you are even more interested in looking after people so aided by the Holy Spirit you devise (let us say) a really effective anti-obesity program.

Wrong way: Same scenario down to being a Christian – you may or may not be. You are looking for ways of promoting your anti-obesity campaign (which we agree is a good thing) you come to see that bringing in religious sanctions will help motivate people. So your campaign says that not being overweight is necessary in order to be a good Christian.

Why is this wrong? Because you have (perhaps inadvertently) reduced saving faith in Jesus to being just the means to a something you consider a “greater good” (public health in this case): this inevitably results in the greater “good” becoming the greater “god”.


This last example: that of using Christianity as a means to promote XYZ cause; is again a lie that is mostly true (as the most effective lies are).

As you let God have a bigger and bigger say in your life, you find that he has PLANS. But his plans are tailor made for you, and something you will have great fun discovering and following in partnership with God. So you may be an activist changing the world – as William Wilberforce was. Or you may diligently and cheerfully do what people think is “just” an ordinary job: in the process greatly please God, and perhaps spread a little happiness to a lot of people. Or you may stay home and raise children who turn out to love God and be well adjusted adults and in the process please God inordinately. And so I could go on but you get to idea.

To let someone firstly make you think that joining their cause is part of believing in Jesus and secondly possibly de-rail you from following the plans God has for you is a double disaster.

The tragedy is that churches are well populated with people whose devotion to this cause or that cause has eclipsed their devotion to Christ. It is sad because they are now dysfunctional Christians, and may even cease being Christians at all. It is sad because they are turning whole churches aside from serving Christ to serving their merely human political platforms. It is also sad because while they are being driven by their own (or the world’s) agenda rather than God’s plan they will go off-track in trying to fix up this broken world and often end up being part of the problem instead of part of the solution.

They will try to recruit you. Resist! There is nothing more important than Jesus and nothing pleases him as much as walking humbly with him on the path he has chosen for you.





Monday, 24 June 2013

Galatians 3:15-29

DOWNLOAD sermon Galatians 3:15-29 June 23 2013
What about the Law then? Well it was more of a signpost and like a builder's straight edge than a ladder for climbing up to heaven.

Morals Post : How I climbed the rest of the cliff with no difficulty!



Yes Last post I was stuck on a (metaphorical) cliff.
Yes this post is late because I couldn't see a way out of my difficulty.
And yes the problem evaporated like the morning mist.

This is how. I remembered a parable I had heard decades ago when I saw it even better illustrated in a film, then I remembered the germ of an idea I had written in a booklet on ethics back in 1990. I applied those and …. hey presto! Problem solved!

Of course I am going to keep you in suspense a little longer – after all it has been a hard week, so why should you get the answer too easily. In the meantime I am going to tell you about the film.

Our family love watching videos together. Recently we re-watched the 1996 film “The Ghost and the Darkness” which stars Val Kilmer as the hero Colonel George Patterson. After the film we were discussing the probability of various parts being true, so naturally we had to resort to Wikipedia to settle the matter. Indeed it was mostly true – the character played by Michael Douglass was fictitious - but there really was a Colonel George Patterson who went to Kenya in March 1898 to build a railway bridge over the Tsavo River, and he did have this amazing adventure.

When Col. Patterson arrived his job was to build a bridge over the Tsavo River for the Kenya – Mombassa railway. Patterson inherited a large multi-national labour force who were already hard at work on the foundations. It looked like an easy assignment.

However, coinciding with Patterson's arrival, grisly deaths started occurring. Workers were dragged from their tents at night and devoured by lions. Patterson and his staff tried every trick in the book. Fires were lit – but to no avail. Thorn barriers were built round the camp – the lions crawled through them. Traps were set, the lions evaded them. Between March and November Patterson claimed some 135 people (mostly villagers: only 40 or so were his workers) were killed.

The work force called these two lions “the Ghost” and “the Darkness” Many, perhaps most believed that these were no ordinary lions but demons in the shape of lions. Some said that as the attacks started when Patterson arrived perhaps he was the cause of this curse. Believing that the creatures, whatever they were, could not be killed, the workers fled and work on the bridge stopped.

Now, with a little poetic licence, let me set a problem for Col. Patterson. He had hunted lions in India, so had some reason for confidence that bullets would kill them. On the other hand he had to date been singularly unsuccessful. So was his confidence mistaken? The workers thought they were demons, against which no rifle could prevail. They were obviously convinced that their belief was correct. They had (OK this bit is the poetic licence I mentioned earlier) done everything to persuade Patterson that guns would have no effect against this scourge. What should he do?

Should he pack away his rifle and call in a priest or even a local witch-doctor to try an exorcism? Should he admit that he was powerless against these forces, and follow his workers in their flight?
Should he go with his own belief in firearms and hunt them down, rifle in hand.

What he did do was build a scaffold and lure the tigers to attack. Then he used his rifle. It was a near thing, the second lion took nine bullets to kill it and even as it died it was trying to get to Patterson. The lions are are now on display in the Chicago museum. They were indeed huge, and certainly unusually cunning and destructive but still definitely flesh-and- blood.

The moral of the story is of course that he had to overcome the temptation to accept the belief system of those around him and use the weapons he had used successfully in the past. And guess what – they worked this time too.

Tune in next week to see how this solved the problem that had me stumped for so long. See if you can guess the answer before then!